Which Assessment tool? (Blackboard vs Turnitin quick guide)

Please note: This TEL handbook is currently work in progress and not the finished article.

This should be thought of as a “quick guide”. It is far from exhaustive in terms of all the possible assessment types but does deal with the most commonly used types at Aston.

If you are selecting a tool based upon the submission type/format this decision chart below should help.

If you are selecting a tool based on the feedback type/format that you would like to use the chart below should help.

Feedback type	Turnitin	Blackboard
Single Overall Comment	YES	YES
Grading Forms	YES	NO
Inline/Annotated comments	YES	YES. However, students cannot download an annotated version of the submission.
Digital Ink	NO	Download the submitted file and annotate using your chosen annotation software and hardware. Reattach file as feedback.
Rubrics	YES	YES
Audio	Record audio in Turnitin but limited to 3mins. Very easy & quick.	An audio file of any length can be attached as feedback. Requires you to record audio outside of Blackboard in “other” software and then export and upload to BB.
Video/screencasts	NO	A video file can be attached as feedback. Requires you to record video outside of Blackboard in “other” software and then export and upload to BB/Kaltura/Panopto
Ability to see student engagement with feedback	YES	NO
Feedback on none submitted assessment	Possible by submitting a feedback document “on behalf” of the student.	Via a manually created grade centre column.